How I Use Apple Music
In my effort to listen to the greatest 500 albums of all time, I joined Apple Music. I've had issues with streaming services in the past as they felt like a bit of a mess. The mess led to a feeling that the only real option was to fall into one of its feeds and not control my music.
I found I can avoid this with the way Apple Music is set up. In the past, I kind of avoided the Library feature and accepted some defaults, which auto-added songs and albums to the Library. This made things not so good. What I'm doing now is treating the online catalog as if it were a giant record store.
The first step was creating a new Library by holding down Option while launching Music on macOS. This creates what should be an empty Library, except it auto-loads all your past purchases (gross). All these purchases can get deleted, which hides them away. You can still get them back if wanted in the future (though it's a bit buried away in your profile). I had previously also downloaded all the purchased music I actually wanted and backed it up in a couple of places, so I'm not too worried about this.
At this point, you have a Music app with nothing in it, perfect. But wait, there is a little more to do. In the Music Settings on iOS, there are toggles to auto-add playlist songs and favorite songs to the Library. I turned both these off, as they will just make a mess. I want my Library to be 100% intentional.
Now, when I want to listen to a new album, I head to the "store". I find the album in Apple Music, then add it to my Library. Only once it's in my Library do I actually listen to it. If I like what I hear, the album can stay. If I don't like it, or it's not something I would actually buy, I delete it (return it to the "store").
This makes it feel like I'm still managing my own Library, which is something I always enjoyed about music, while still having access to everything. On my mission to listen to all these albums, I can add a few albums at a time to my Library, listen to them at my leisure, then decide their fate.
It took me a long time to really "get it" with Apple Music, but now that I found this workflow, I quite like it. As much as I tried different things with Spotify and YouTube Music, everything always felt like a mess with little hope of bringing order to the madness. While my new workflow may seem old-school and antiquated, I find there is a certain charm and nostalgia in picking out albums in this way. Getting to know the artist, by listening to their work in the way they wanted, also seems much better than random auto-generated playlists where I have no idea who any of the artists are… it could all be AI for all I know.
I've already gone outside the 500 list a few times to check out a few newer albums I heard about. I went through the same process of adding the album to my Library, listening to it, and then either keeping or removing it. It makes it feel like I'm borrowing it from the library or a friend to see what I think before committing. I always used to shy away from using "Delete from Library" in the past, as it seemed so final, but it's not. I'm getting more comfortable with deleting albums, which makes it OK to add them just for a listen or two.
All of this prevents me from being overloaded by the endless choice when going into Apple Music's Home or New areas. Those areas are more like the choice one feels when walking into a record store, which is temporary. Then you make your choices, and go home to your small locally library that is manageable and not so overwhelming.